A Belleview engineer’s effort to reduce nearly $20,000 in water and sewer expenses for a small commercial development has hit a roadblock, with city commissioners denying a request for a single master water meter serving four office and warehouse units. The decision came during the Belleview City Commission’s Nov. 17 meeting, following concerns raised earlier this month about the city’s system development charges and whether its calculations reflect the water needs of small businesses.
The dispute centers on a commercial development at 7025 SE Highway 25A, consisting of four units. Each unit is approximately 1,250 square feet and contains one restroom. At the Nov. 3 commission meeting, Ed Abshier, representing the property owner, questioned the city’s requirement to calculate utility charges using a minimum anticipated consumption of 150 gallons of water per day for each commercial unit.
Abshier argued that actual consumption would likely be closer to 50 gallons per day per unit. Under the city’s existing fee structure, the development faces an estimated $19,289 in water and sewer expenses. That figure includes $11,784 in system development charges, $3,310 in meter connection fees, deposits and inspection costs, and another $4,195 in water-service work. Abshier requested permission to install a single master meter serving all four units, along with a reduction in the system development charges.
However, city officials pointed to requirements established by the St. Johns River Water Management District, which oversees water resource permitting in the region. In a Nov. 5 email to Belleview Public Works Director Bob Titterington, district Supervising Regulatory Hydrologist Daniel Gilmore cited a condition of the city’s use permit requiring all service connections to be metered.
Gilmore claimed that individual meters help promote water conservation by allowing customers to monitor their own consumption. Master meters, he wrote, do not provide the same level of accountability.
The city’s Public Works Department subsequently recommended denying the request, maintaining the existing system development charges unless additional documentation justified a reduction. Under Belleview’s current code, an applicant seeking an alternative calculation may submit at least one year of actual water consumption records from a substantially identical facility.
The issue also drew concerns from Commissioner Robert “Bo” Smith during the Nov. 3 meeting. Smith acknowledged that high utility impact fees have discouraged small businesses from opening in Belleview and suggested the charges deserved a closer look.
And those costs are scheduled to keep climbing. Under a previously adopted city ordinance, Belleview’s water and sewer system development charges increased to $19.64 per gallon of anticipated daily usage in January 2026. That is scheduled to rise to $21.56 in 2027 and $23.48 in 2028. At the same daily calculation used for the four-unit development, the current $11,784 in system development charges would climb to $14,088 by 2028, an increase of $2,304, before connection fees and other expenses are added.
